Thinking Without the Circle: Marine Plastic and Global Ethics

Excited to have found Worldly IR fascinating and mind invigorating articles. Trying to mine the wonderful references/links to learn more. May have to join Political Geography to access the full Marine Ethics and Global Plastics paper. J Barton http://www.littoralartproject.com

Audra Mitchell's avatarWorldly

My new article on marine plastic and global ethics in Political Geography is now available as a free download here until 2 July, 2015. Here’s the abstract: 

Gyre 1 by Audra Mitchell and Liam Kelly. All rights reserved. Gyre 1 by Audra Mitchell and Liam Kelly. All rights reserved.2015. Here’s a little bit about the article: 

Marine plastic has received significant attention as a spectacle of consumer waste and ecosystemic fragility, but there has been little discussion of its ethical implications. This essay argues that marine plastic poses a direct challenge to the basic frameworks of global ethics. These frameworks are dominated by the image of the ‘circle’, an abstract boundary intended to separate ‘humanity’ from the rest of the universe and insulate it against harm. However, this article argues that marine plastic undermines the ‘circle’ in two ways. First, it embodies conditions of ‘hyper-relationality’, including entanglement and the properties of toxicity, that penetrate the boundaries of ‘the circle’…

View original post 106 more words

Still Life

After focusing on taking precise photographs  of 40 different objects individually, for the Guide to Beach Litter,  I decided  to take a few sessions  selecting out objects to combine together  to create a series of simple ‘still life’ images …..

plastic spoon    

flip flop & plastic rocks

…… positioning objects together quickly suggested narrative ideas

‘flipflop trailing plastic rocks’ and ‘Syringe resting on ‘plastic rock’

syringe & plastic rocks

These simple still life’s put me in mind of Eileen Agar’s surrealist assemblages in particular her     ‘Marine Object’ 1939 (below right), in which she assembled a natural rock, horn and star fish.

imagesInspired I set about making my own ‘Marine Object’  using three different beach litter objects I found on beaches this year – ‘rocks’,  fishing line and a spoon. The significant difference being that they are all plastic and require no specialist conserving .

my marine object 1

Working in the littoral zones I have frequently felt like I was inhabiting a  surreal dream/nightmare landscape not dissimilar to Dali’s ‘Mountain Lake’ or  ‘The Persistence of Memory’. Melted plastic bags could quite easily replace the slumped clock over the branches of the tree  in the Memory landscpae

index dali  dali lake

With such thoughts in mind the simple ‘still life’s’ quickly developed into sets and introducing my architectural models the surrealist ideas of playing with shifting scale,  introducing distortion to create confusion and tension all came  flooding into my notes.  Useful ideas which I intend to use in my animation over the next year.

working in ESW ESW staging business mand & plastic products

plastic frame  through the view finder  ESW notes
Photographs taken in the Edinburgh Sculpture Workshop July 2015

 

Photo shoot

Over the last few days I have sorted through hundred’s of litter items collected across the littoral zones  of  over 20 beaches  on the west coast and more recently Shetland to select 40 items identified  with Dr Cowie  two weeks ago for possible inclusion in the Guide to Beach Litter.

trays litter items

My aim is to select the ‘best’ samples that are representational of what might be found on the beach.

set up seaweed cropped
So far 20 items have been photographed  each item being  shot multiple times on a selection of settings to ensure I achieve the best image possible. The items will be  digitally ‘cut out’ and positioned on the Guide layout . My aim is that the Guide should echo the  natural history field guides where the species are collaged together on each page.

positioning items processing images

But before the processing can begin there are another 20 items to choose, group together, position, reposition and photograph.

caps

I estimate that the ‘Guide to Beach Litter’ will cost £3,000 to produce. £1,100 has been pledged  which will cover the photographing , processing and layout of the work . I still need to raise  £1,900 to  cover the printing  – ideas of how to raise this would be much appreciated.   Many thanks.

Donations to the project can be made through Paypal  check out how to do this on the Sponsorship page.

Celebrating – World Environment Day

To celebrate World Environment Day #WED2015 today I crossed the Clyde for a meeting with marine biologist Dr Phillip Cowie at the Millport Field Study Centre FSC on Cumbrae to begin to map out the ‘Guide to Beach Litter’.

Fairly beach  ferry toCumbrae
We began by making a long list of 40 commonly seen litter items, trying to cover items made of different materials , coming from a range of different sources, i.e. originating from the land , the sea and whether they are from commercial or beach users. I will circulate this list around groups such as the Marine Conservation Society  Shetland Dunna Chuck Bruck group and other organisations /groups cleaning beaches around the Scottish coast to see if the list is representational . If anyone reading this list feels I should consider including an item I have not listed that they see in significant numbers please get in touch – use the comment box below or e mail  littoralartproject@btinternt.com

Long list
PLASTIC 1. fibres 2. bottles 3. Gunwads/cartridges 4. Ropes 5.Food wrappers 6.Mussel pegs 7. String /cord 8. Caps/lids 9.barrels 10. Wipes 11.cigarette lighters 12. Drinking straws 13. Work gloves 14.fishing nets/pieces 15.fishing line 16. Melted plastic rocks 17.Strapping bands 18.Plastic pieces 19.Bags 20. Pack Yokes 21. Syringes 22. Pellets/nurdles 23.cotton bud sticks 24.tampon applicators 25.sanitary ware strips
POLYSTYRENE /STYRENE 26..Polystyrene pieces 27.Foam
METAL 28.Aerosol cans 29.Drinks cans 30.BBQ disposable 31. Scrap metal 32.Batteries 33.Foil food containers
RUBBER 34.Balloons 35.Tyres WOOD 36.Pallets/crate GLASS 37.Bottles CERAMIC 38.pottery   OTHER 39. Tarmac 40. Concrete

Millport visit 2  Millport Notes

Our conversation on litter items ranged widely interestingly discussing the least hazardous materials first – glass and ceramics – which once they have been rounded with the wave action they pose a relatively small hazard to marine organisms the wider environment and ourselves. From here we launched into the plastic abyss and we noted down the vast array of hazards they pose to all organisms including our selves touching on the research studies now taking place of the effects of plastics if/when eaten by us in seafood.

Strapping black Burwick  DSCF9521 Plastic bag scottish CU Burn beach melted rope
The plastic items will undoubtedly make up the biggest section on the guide, as more and more items like work gloves we call ‘rubber gloves’ are now commonly made out plastic. A reflection of the plastic nature of our world . Clear images of the litter items, like the one below will be used in the Guide with simple descriptions which will include usual dimensions and the material/s

Plastic Rock
This #WED2015 has been a wonderfully positive day thanks to donations given in response to my Crowd Funding appeal last month.

The next step is to raise the remaining money needed. So far £675 has been received and this will cover the photography work and first draft of the text , the remaining pledged money (another £530 ) will cover the consultation process, editing, design and layout work. I am still looking to raise £1,800 to print the Guide, please get in touch with any suggestions.
New and pledged donations can be made through PayPal using the project email address littoralartproject@btinternet.com press ‘pay for goods & services’. If in doubt go to the Sponsorship page.  Don’t forget to leave a message if you would like to receive a reward of a Guide or beach litter key ring. Many thanks.      I will keep you all updated on the progress of this piece of artwork.

 

 

Sharing ideas – Ragged University Talk

On Thursday evening I embraced  the  ethos of the Ragged University’s talks: ‘to share ideas you are passionate about and to learn something new’ and I enjoyed illustrating my ‘News from the Littoral Zone’ at the Counting House in Edinburgh. The evening also included a mind stretching talk by  Susan Brown from Manchester University on Sustainable Education and allowed the audience and myself to join in with the current thinking on educational approaches to ecologically aware education

The audience was wonderfully  attentive and I was happy to illustrate my research process of exploring the littoral Zones on the NW coast of Scotland  through images taken over the past 2 years  that I have  shared in this blog.  These included my initial shocking strand-line walks, learning survey methods, related hazards and the longevity of respective materials found, plus my trials to creatively share my findings with local community members. Take a look back through the posts.

I began by passing around  evidence bags  of litter items collected over the past two years from 18 beaches and exhibited during my residency at An Talla Solais, Ullapool’s Arts Centre during my residency in 2013 and then shown as part of my installation at Ullapool Museum in 2014.

evidence bags 1

I then shared my thoughts on how I am now honing down my research  findings to be able to focus on specific findings that are the most poignant to me and that inspire me to make strong vital imagery.  Item wise I am now looking in more depth at 3 of the less easily seen litter items found.

Gun Wads: plastic wadding to keep the ammunition in place   either in a gun-barrel or in a paper or metal shell.

IMG_4454

180 plastic wads were collected last autumn on beaches  around Reiff on the Coigach peninsula by committed local beach cleaners concerned  by the fact that these  ‘wads’ have been found to significantly contribute to the death of porpoises, dolphins and turtles.Which is understandable when you view the gun wads floating in the sea as they are so similar to squid. Ecowad alternatives are available.

gun cartridges our contribrition to the ocean conveyor belt

Last week on Shetland I witnessed plastic gun wads on every beach I visited, as there is no known shooting activity on the islands, the Shetland Amenity Trust ‘Dunna Chuck Bruck’ team that I was working with thought it probable that they originated from the from the same place that the lobster tags washed up traced back to Canada’s east coast.   If we follow the conveyor belt of the ocean currents  round it is therefore likely that the  gun wads dropped on Scotland’s NW coast will be ending up on along the eastern Seaboard of America at some point.

Micro-fibres: degrading particles of plastic litter  e.g. rope, bags sacks, cord

IMG_4455

Even on the cleanest looking beaches, where no obvious  litter items are seen,  I have  found micro-fibres laced within sand grains or caught up in/on the seaweed. On mass the fibres are easily visible but when not visible they can be seen easily amongst collected sand grains or seaweed with a hand lens or USB magnifier.   Marine Biologist Dr Phillip Cowie at Millport Field Study Centre explained filter feeding organisms  such as Prawns, flat fish and even sand hoppers are being recorded with such fibres in their guts.

Plastic rocks: melted plastic waste, formed by burning plastic litter on the beaches

IMG_4456

Plastic rocks are perhaps one of the hardest litter items to ‘see’  as the process of burning so many different coloured plastic materials together, often results in  range of grey muted tones which blend in easily with the beach pebbles . I have recorded most of these ‘rocks’ in the mid zones of the beach as they are one of the densest of the plastic items and are less prone to being wind blown.

As I explained in my last post  the melted plastic rock  has now been named  ‘plastiglomerate’ by a Canadian research team and their research findings have led them to argue that the proliferation of the plastic rocks around the world can be seen as a marker horizon of human pollution.

Plastic Rock

I explained that I felt that this broad project knowledge was vital to gain before I could begin to envisage the series of  visual and performance artworks that I am now planning. I am presently working with Shetland Amenity Trust and Highland Arts organisations to raise funding to make the Littoral Art Exhibition possible in the coming year.  I intend to make installations and related stop frame animations focusing/using plastigomerate’s and the micro-fibres that I find practically on every beach I investigate.

Many thanks to Alex Dunedin who organises the Ragged University Talks, and to Susan Brown who through her fascinating talk on Sustainable Education has enabled to me see how my practice fits well in the Sustainable Education models currently being discussed and developed.

 

 

Exploring ideas in Shetland 2

16.5.15  I headed northwest on Shetlands mainland to observe a small part of  Shetlands  incredibly complex geological landscape.  Rocks found on these Isles span  3 billion years covering every era from the Precambrian to the Carboniferous and is the reason why Shetland is one of the three GeoParks in Scotland .  The most dramatic of these landscapes must be seen at Eshaness point (below) where the volcanic landscape which stretches out into the Atlantic .

Esha Ness

The  banded cliffs are the result of repeated lava flows from the nearby Eshaness volcano active 350 million years ago. The cliffs and the information they hold about past time periods have made me reflect again on what will ‘mark’ our time on this planet.  Instantly what comes to mind is the plastic ‘rocks’ I first noticed and collected on Isle May a year ago and have picked up on beaches here on Burwick beach during our big beach clean and today  on Breawick  beach (below) near  Stenness.

IMG_4382

For obvious reasons this is one of the most un-seen forms of beach litter, the melted plastic is often in muted tones and can  through time can be rounded like stone into pebble-like forms almost indistinguishable from the stones around them. Its rare that I find a beach now without these plastic ‘rocks’

I use the word ‘rock’ ironically but at the same time that I was collecting samples of this form of beach litter on  Isle Martin’s Back Beach I became aware of the work of a team of scientist’s led by Patricia L Corcoran  ( full credits below) who made similar observations on Kamilo Beach on the island of Hawaii in 2013 went on to name melted plastic rocks  ‘plastiglomerate’ . Their research findings and  extrapolation bares chilling reading especially as they go on to argue that the proliferation of this plastic rocks around the world can be seen as a marker horizon of human pollution .  The plastic rocks having been formed by our actions which have produced the plastic litter that is washed up and dropped in vast quantities around the world and is then burned .

Burn Beach 1 Burn beach sign Burn beach melted rope
Communities close to remote beaches be they in Hawaii or here in Scotland when faced with ever increasing mounds of plastic waste often try and reduce the litter by burning it. Its an understandable reaction especially on beaches like these. But the process of burning the plastic on the beaches  releases chemicals such as carbon monoxide, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and dioxins which can cause neurological symptoms, cancer, and hormonal disruptions in humans. The creation of this new metamorphic  ‘rock’ layer is a sad addition to our shores , Geoparks and planet.

Scall air

As I head back to the Scottish mainland today I take with me new thoughts and understandings from what I have witnessed on the beaches in Shetlands Geopark and on the beaches with enthusiastic children. My week in Shetland has been a powerful experience meeting enthusiastic people in many organisations across Shetland – interested in the potential of a joint  project that the Shetland Amenity Trust team and I are working to raise funding to make happen.

Research ref: An Anthropogenic marker horizon in the future rock record

Patricia L Cocoran, Dept of Earth Sciences, University of Western Ontario Canada . Charles J Moore Algalita Marine Research Institute California USA Kelly Jazac Dept Visual Arts, Ontario Canada

 

Exploring ideas in the Shetland Isles (1)

13.5.15: Arrived Sumburgh Airport

DSCF9488
Plastic toy plane found on Shetland beach last week

I flew to the Shetland Isles to explore ideas in person with Sita Goudie of the Shetland Amenity Trust to  discuss ideas of creatively working together  to  deliver a Shetland Littoral Art Project  in the future. I was met by Jane Outram the Trust’s Environmental Awareness Officer who within the first hour introduced me to Angela Hunt manager of Sumburgh Head and gave me a fascinating tour of this  fantastic heritage centre with working ligthouse, bird reserve and arts venue.
DSCF9427 DSCF9449 DSCF9454 DSCF9443

Sumburgh Head Lighthouse has played many important roles saving mariners lives  and through out the war with its temporary radar station.

DSCF9436 DSCF9464 DSCF9470 DSCF9468

The Lighthouse  seemed a pertinent start to our discussions together as we walked passed a chute in the wall down which waste used to be dropped into the sea and then examined a metre high bone from a sperm whale’s head which had washed up nearby tangled in fishing nets. Some patterns of behavior have changed dropping waste directly from lighthouses is illegal in most countries, but its estimated that we dump 6.4 million tonnes of litter into the sea every year.

15.5.15  I was able to join  77 pupil plus teachers from the Scalloway  Primary School for the last 2015 Da Voar Redd Up (Spring Clean up) event organised by the Shetland Amenity Trust (SAT). The S.A.T  have managed to encourage more and more of the communities around Shetland to join in with collecting litter from beaches, roadsides cliff tops all events are catalogued on the Dunna Chuck Bruck Facebook page

Friday’s task was to clean Burwick beach a mile NW from the school. This is the third year that the school as risen to the task and spirits were high as 5-12year old children walked over the hill and down to the beach.

Burwick beach  MS before 2

The beach I took in was as bad as the beach that started me off on this Littoral Journey in 2012

IMG_4321 DSCF9496 DSCF9521 DSCF9507

For me the mounds of  broken down rope fibres 1/2 m deep that almost created a plastic raised beach at the top of the littoral zone was painful to see.  As I  scooped and pulled at the matted fibres to bag it up. I was thinking that this is where rolls of seaweed should have been lying, thoughts especially coupled with the knowledge that hundreds of thousands of organisms will have ingested such fibres the effects of which are still to be understood.

IMG_4331

Burwick beach  WS before   DSCF9530

In total 254 bags of litter were filled and removed from the beach, while  there was still much left to do a significant difference was made.  Well done to everyone who took place especially the youngest members of the team. Millions of reasons to work together to devise creative ideas to help to change our behavior which presently allows this to happen.

Exciting Schedule May-June 2015

 May

Appeal Update: Over £1,000 has been pledged towards producing the ‘Guide to Beach Litter’ this will  pay for photographing found litter items, researching and writing the text, plus the design and print costs. If you pledged or would like to donate please send donations via PayPal

May 13th:  Shetland Visit 2015  I fly to Shetland to to meet the Shetland Amenity Trust whose work addressing marine and beach litter is second to none in the UK.  They have been working to keep beaches clean for over 19 years and annually lead the Da Voar Redd Up litter clean-ups across the islands which last last year involved over 7,000 volunteers. I am looking forward to joining the last day of the Redd Up in Scalloway on Burwick

Shetland_UK_location_map with position

I will be visiting  a selection of beaches,  schools and key organisations to explore the idea of collaborating with the Shetland Amenity Trust to deliver the Littoral sci-art project across the Islands over the next two years.

May 28th: Edinburgh Talk  I will be giving an illustrated talk  ‘News from the Littoral Zone’ which is my account of my processes, findings and ideas on the Littoral Art Project as part of the Ragged University series of talks at the Counting House, Nicholson Street, EH8. My talk will be followed by Susan Brown talking about Sustainability for Education. This is a free event, no booking necessary, all welcome 7pm

June

June 5th: World Environment Day Event   Littoral Sci-Art Lab installation/performance location to be announced.

DSCF9400

 

 

#IVoted

casting votes for beaches 1

Over the last few weeks I have carefully cast my marks within the ‘littoral zones’ of our coastline.Marks  writ large on Luce Bay (Dumfries) with lines of washed up plastic gun wads threaded together

casting votes for beaches 2

Bold marks made with washed up sections of plastic prawn boxes

mixed col X white X Purplr & white X

Blue X red X green X

Small marks on Portobello beach using beach-goers litter, spoons, pens, cotton bud sticks , plastic stirrers plus commercial fishing tags and cord. These marks are addressed to all the party’s regardless of their colour.

Please cast your vote for the marine environment and the arts today @LittoralArt #cleanseas #cleanbeaches    Check out what the Littoral Art Project is doing, send me your comments, press the follow button on this page and consider supporting funding the work of this project.

Above all vote for a cleaner and creative world!

Beach style campaign

My  campaign trip to the Dumfries coastline  to raise last minute support for the ‘Guide to Beach Litter’ developed into an exciting days work on Luce Bay Beach. The bay is vast and the beach extensive and has a great mix of sand, shingle and rocks. Perfect for anyone’s bank holiday.  Thankfully the day was bright and sunny though the brisk very cold winds kept all but the hardy seaside visitors away.

IMG_4383 IMG_4387 IMG_4424 IMG_4386  

I set the van up as a Sci-Art beach investigation unit alongside the beach, highlighting a selection of my findings so far  and open to all  beach goers. Discussions with intrigued visitors ranged widely from beach litter, to concern about the increasing acid levels in the sea and to fears of over fishing. On the beach I began mocking up a ‘Guide to Beach Litter’ using the litter I collected from along the strandline. The process of laying out the litter made me realise how complex the decisions to decide what to include in the Guide will be, in order to highlight the different : materials ,  hazards, and groups of people responsible for the litter.

DSCF9316 DSCF9383  particles in petridish
The item that drew most attention was in fact the collection of minute  fragments of mixed platic pieces and fibres that are found in the sand and amongst the seaweed.  I explained that these fibres and micro plastic particles are now being ingested by fish and marine organisms. The conversations reminded me of my dismay at being told by marine biologist Dr Philip Cowie  that organisms as small as sandhoppers had been found to ingest micro-plastic fibres.  As I had the ‘lab’ all set up I placed a (found) dead sand- hopper under the microscope and placed fibres beneath it to explore the visual connection. An idea I intend to pursue.

DSCF9408   DSCF9400

I was asked what I was filming as I shook a glass flaskcontain in front of the camera.  I explained that I was experimenting with the idea of how it would feel to be in the sea surrounded by plastic particles rather than plankton.

DSCF9346 DSCF9359

Flask contents : water , plastic particles and fibres plus architectural model  figure.

 ‘Well you have opened my eyes  with that, I never realised that’s what happens’                                     Alan local man

Yours is a great project and is doing a great job to make us aware of our environment. When you think about it the way we live has to change! ‘ Hugh from Whithorn

To celebrate these  encouraging comments in the Littoral Art Project’s work,  I spent the evening translating their verbal votes of confidence into visual votes on the beach.  As the tide receding I marked out  two X’s  using ‘litter lines’ made of prawn boxes and gun wads stitched together on Isle Martin last May.   One for #cleanseas and the other for #cleanbeaches

IMG_4392

A full compliment of X’s will follow soon with the appeal and sponsorship update. Many thanks to everyone who pledged support, together there has been over £1,000 pledged. I am presently setting up a  [donate] button on the blog and I hope everyone will be happy to donate their pledges via this PayPal system instead of via kickstarter. Thank you!

IMG_4402